comprising New York Yankees: Mickey Mantle, Charley Smith x2, Tom Tresh x2, Fred Talbot, Jake Gibbs x2, Roy White, Al Downing, Bobby Murcer, Mel Stottlemyre, Steve Hamilton x3, Jim Bouton, Dooley Womack, Fritz Peterson, Elston Howard, Horace Clarke, Joe Pepitone, Ruben Amaro, Hal Reniff; New York Mets: Tommy Davis, Don Cardwell, Roy McMillan, John Stephenson, Ken Boyer, Clean Jones, Al Luplow x2, Tug McGraw, Ed Kranepool, Jerry Grote, Jack Hamilton, Johnny Lewis, Ron Swoboda, Chuck Hiller, Bob Shaw, Jack Fisher, Ed Bressoud.